Sitting here playing a little bit this morning and thought I'd throw a random question out to Blogland to see what you guys think.
Here's an image I took on a recent visit to Caerphilly Castle:

So the thing is I thought this might make quite an interesting study in monochrome... but that raises a question in my mind 
Because I didn't shoot the shoot the image in B&W, to render the image in monochrome I'd have to desaturate it. Images often lend themselves though to a little extra manipulation...
Here are six alternatives for a monochrome version of my image and what I'd like you to do is rate them for me...
The images are numbered 1 to 6 and are clickable so you can view larger versions of them if you wish. No need to rate all six unless you want to, but please rate your choices in order of preference; eg. 6, 3, 2, 5, etc.
Thanking you in anticipation.







